📊 Grid Convergence Index (GCI) — ASME V&V 20
Quantify spatial discretization numerical uncertainty in CFD simulations across 3 grid levels (Roache 1998 & ASME V&V 20-2009 Standard). Computes apparent order $p$, Richardson extrapolation $\phi_{ext}$, and $GCI_{fine}$.
📝 Three-Grid Verification Setup
ASME V&V 20 Formulations:
$$r_{21} = \frac{h_2}{h_1}, \quad r_{32} = \frac{h_3}{h_2}, \quad \epsilon_{21} = \phi_2 - \phi_1$$ $$p = \frac{1}{\ln(r_{21})} \left| \ln\left|\frac{\epsilon_{32}}{\epsilon_{21}}\right| + q(p) \right|$$ $$\phi_{ext}^{21} = \frac{r_{21}^p \phi_1 - \phi_2}{r_{21}^p - 1}$$ $$GCI_{fine}^{21} = \frac{F_s \cdot e_a^{21}}{r_{21}^p - 1}$$
$$r_{21} = \frac{h_2}{h_1}, \quad r_{32} = \frac{h_3}{h_2}, \quad \epsilon_{21} = \phi_2 - \phi_1$$ $$p = \frac{1}{\ln(r_{21})} \left| \ln\left|\frac{\epsilon_{32}}{\epsilon_{21}}\right| + q(p) \right|$$ $$\phi_{ext}^{21} = \frac{r_{21}^p \phi_1 - \phi_2}{r_{21}^p - 1}$$ $$GCI_{fine}^{21} = \frac{F_s \cdot e_a^{21}}{r_{21}^p - 1}$$
📊 Verification Uncertainty Report
Verification Summary
Richardson Extrapolated Value ($\phi_{ext}^{21}$ at $h \to 0$)
149.514
Fine Grid $GCI_{fine} = \mathbf{\pm 6.061\%}$ | Apparent Order $p = \mathbf{1.21}$
Asymptotic Range: EXCELLENT: Grid within asymptotic range (0.95 <= AR <= 1.05). (Ratio $AR = \mathbf{1.032}$)
Apparent Order ($p$)1.21
Fine $GCI_{21}$6.06 %
Medium $GCI_{32}$10.2 %
Rel Error ($e_a$)3.09 %
Ratio $r_{21}$1.5
Ratio $r_{32}$1.5
📈 Solution Convergence vs Normalized Grid Spacing $h/h_1$
📋 Grid Convergence Analysis Breakdown
| Parameter | Value | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Convergence Type | Monotonic Convergence | Monotonic / Oscillatory behavior |
| Apparent Order ($p$) | 1.215 | ASME V&V 20 solution |
| Richardson Extrap ($\phi_{ext}$) | 149.514 | Continuum solution at $h \to 0$ |
| Fine Grid GCI | 6.061 % | Numerical uncertainty on fine mesh |
| Medium Grid GCI | 10.23 % | Numerical uncertainty on medium mesh |
| Asymptotic Ratio ($AR$) | 1.032 | Target $AR \approx 1.0$ |
Fortran Solver Raw Output:
=============================================================== THERMOFLUIDCALC — ASME V&V 20 GRID CONVERGENCE INDEX (GCI) =============================================================== Dimension = 3 Safety Factor Fs = 1.2500 Fine Size h1 = 1.000000E-03 Fine Solution phi1 = 1.426000E+02 Medium Size h2 = 1.500000E-03 Medium Solution phi2= 1.382000E+02 Coarse Size h3 = 2.250000E-03 Coarse Solution phi3= 1.310000E+02 --------------------------------------------------------------- Ratio r21 (h2/h1) = 1.5000 Ratio r32 (h3/h2) = 1.5000 Convergence Type = Monotonic Convergence Apparent Order p = 1.2146 Richardson Extrap = 1.495143E+02 Approx Error ea21 = 3.085554E-02 Approx Error ea21 % = 3.0856% Extrap Error e_ext = 4.624498E-02 Extrap Error e_ext %= 4.6245% GCI Fine (GCI_21) = 6.060910E-02 GCI Fine (GCI_21) % = 6.0609% GCI Medium (GCI_32) = 1.023362E-01 GCI Medium (GCI_32)%= 10.2336% Asymptotic Ratio AR = 1.0318 --------------------------------------------------------------- Asymptotic Check = EXCELLENT: Grid within asymptotic range (0.95 <= AR <= 1.05). =============================================================== --- GCI CONVERGENCE PROFILE --- Grid_Index h_norm phi_val GCI_pct 0 0.000000E+00 1.495143E+02 0.000000E+00 1 1.000000E+00 1.426000E+02 6.060910E+00 2 1.500000E+00 1.382000E+02 1.023362E+01 3 2.250000E+00 1.310000E+02 1.023362E+01 --- END GCI PROFILE ---